Cara Jarvis longs to be part of the in-crowd at her new school. In an effort to impress the town hunk Brandon, she befriends Grace, a girl with Down Syndrome, a friendship she tries to hide when she meets popular girls Skylar and Quinn. When Skylar loses her bid to be on the homecoming Court, she sets it up for Grace to win Homecoming Queen... as the Senior Prank. Grace wins, is publicly and cruelly humiliated and Skylar rigs it so Cara takes the blame. Cara must now win back Brando, restore her friendship with Grace and save her reputation at her school.