Welcome to None's film reviews page. None has written 1 reviews and rated 22 films.
See our review guidelines and terms.
There's a kind of semi-spoiler in this review: its vague enough not to matter, but it doesn't affect your enjoyment of the film, it may even increase it.
The film mostly got a balance between the responding to the threat of terrorism, and maintaining the West's belief in universal human rights. At one point it was thrown in as an established fact that interrogation by torture never delivers any information of value. That is more of an attractive and heart warming Western concept than an established fact. The acting and scenes were mostly very well done - altho I did think that the CIA director (Meryl Streep) would not be tempted to engage in a loose conversation with a stranger, just because the latter piqued her sense of morality - but it was necessary for the plot to move forward at that point. If you like movies like Black Hawk Down, Zero Dark Thirty, or the Hurt Locker, this will be right up your street.
The annoying part is the ending. At this point it becomes clear that the 2 different storylines, that we thought were unfolding at the same time, were actually separated by one week. So basically, you've spent 90 minutes getting into a story which is not the real story. Why do they do this? I speculate that the director wanted to make you feel the same sense of bewilderment, confusion, frustration, helplessness and unfairness that an innocent victim of rendition feels because the things happening to him just don't add up.
Brilliant, it worked! It did feel all 5 of those irritating feelings. However, it wasn't how I'd planned to spend my Friday evening, and honestly speaking, I don't see how this deception added to the power of the plot.
If the director hadn't tried to be such a smart arse, I could have given it 5 stars.
Find answers to frequently asked questions and contact us should you need to
See prices and levels and find out how Cinema Paradiso service works
Invite your friends to join and get free subscription each month