After WWII, Hollywood noir began to accommodate the documentary style naturalism seen in Italian neorealism. The most influential film in that style was The Naked City, but I prefer Call Northside 777 which has a more moving and suspenseful story and a knockout ending.
It was based on actual events and sourced from newspaper articles. James Stewart plays a Chicago reporter who is alerted by a mother's offer of a reward saved up through 11 years working as a cleaner to investigate a miscarriage of justice which resulted in her innocent son and another being sent to prison for 99 years.
Hathaway made a few of these docu-noirs, with the standard big city locations, and a powerful, declamatory narration. Stewart is nuanced as a cynical newsman who slowly becomes obsessed with the faulty verdict from so long ago that many of the protagonists are dead.
Compared with Italian neorealism this is processed, mainstream stuff, but it was still groundbreaking in American cinema and unashamed to show realistic poverty, particularly among immigrants. The story of the innocent victims of institutional corruption is pure noir, though the upbeat outcome is less typical.
FILM & REVIEW Before WWII Jimmy Stewart was seen as a lightweight comic actor but having seen combat and ending as a full Colonel returned looking for meatier parts and this was his breakthrough film. A terrific true life journalistic investigation around the murder of a Chicago cop 11 years ago during prohibition where two Polish men were convicted . As ad is placed in the Chicago Times and is picked up by cynical newspaper man Mcneal (Stewart). The ad is placed by one of the convicted men’s Mother who has scraped together the money and wants McNeals help. He is doubtful at first but as his editor Cobb points out it’s a human interest story and that sells papers. Soon his mail sack is full and his phone never stops ringing with messages of support so agrees to go to the State Penn to interview one of the convicts (Conte) and while still not convinced begins to dig deeper. It’s the classic little guy vs the system movie that Stewart plays so well and it’s really gripping as he too becomes convinced of his innocence. It makes full use of new technology with lie detectors , mini cameras and photographs sent over phone wires all aiding the case. It placed the benchmark for most of Stewart’s career and it’s a cracking film - 4/5
A reporter investigates a case of a man who may have been wrongly imprisoned. Once you get past the clumsy narration at the start, this drama is quite interesting. However it is based on a true story, and the film came out before all of that story had been resolved, so it does feel like it is missing something or as if more could happen.