Reed Walker-Silverman’s second film, after A Love Song, follows Dusty Fraser, a Colorado rancher trying to rebuild after wildfire wipes out his home and livelihood. At its best, Rebuilding notices the right things: a beer by the fire, glow-in-the-dark stars on a trailer wall, the small acts of care that keep people going when everything else has fallen away. The score is spare, the skies are lovely, and the film has a real feel for the quiet routines of simply getting through the day.
The trouble is that it never quite becomes more than that. Josh O’Connor is watchable enough, but the performance feels oddly easy, more charm than character, and his accent slips often enough to pull you out of it. Lily LaTorre leaves more of a mark, while Amy Madigan gets one brief scene that does in seconds what the rest of the film spends too long circling.
Walker-Silverman is clearly a humane filmmaker, and something decent and caring sits at the centre of this. But decent and caring only get you so far. Too often Rebuilding mistakes gentleness for depth. Nicely made, well meant, and ultimately a bit too slight.