Tone is the problem. Or rather, tones—plural—vying for dominance like jealous siblings. The Young Poisoner’s Handbook can’t decide whether it wants to be a sardonic true-crime character study or a grotesque farce. The result is a film that feels oddly weightless, despite all the poisoning.
Based on the life of Graham Young, it charts his journey from precocious sociopath to calculating killer, with a heavy dose of ironic detachment. But the irony feels brittle, the humour forced. The performances are fine—Hugh O’Conor does a decent job of making Graham eerie yet oddly flat—but there’s no real insight, only affectation.
The film flirts with satire, especially in the institutional scenes, but never lands a strong point. It’s too glib to be disturbing, too arch to be moving. There’s potential here—a chilling story and a killer concept—but it’s buried under tonal whiplash and a script that keeps smirking at its own cleverness.
This handbook might be better left unread.