Claudette Colbert wakes on a train to Boston with no memory of boarding it. It’s a cracking opening, and for a while Douglas Sirk keeps me as rattled as she is. Then the film starts explaining itself, and it never stops.
Colbert holds the whole thing together. The trouble is that Alison needs to be easy to fool, and this is a woman who’d spot a con from across the room. The script keeps asking her to forget how sharp she is. Don Ameche makes a suitably creepy husband, all soft voice and fake concern, though his scheme involves so much hypnosis, sedatives and staged nonsense that I started wondering whether her fortune was worth this much admin. Robert Cummings brings some welcome warmth, even if his arrival feels like the screenplay booking a spare husband in advance.
Gaslight had me fearing for Ingrid Bergman’s sanity. Here I mostly drummed my fingers while Colbert caught up.
Stylish, well acted, and lumbered with a villain whose plan needed a ruthless editor.