When Dave & Karl attempt to steal the Scarecrow from farmer Caleb's field, Dave is shot and his soul is given new life as the terrifying Scarecrow. One by one the Scarecrow dispatches anyone who stands between him and the object of his desire - Mary, his former girlfriend. As the bodies pile up, the Scarecrow kidnaps Mary, dragging her back to the field to resurrect her soul inside a Scarecrow body. Karl races to the rescue but is killed - then resurrected as another Scarecrow! Now as the two Scarecrows battle, Mary must stop the creature determined to make her his bride!