Big Bloated Glossy Blob of Muddled Mediocrity - with an all-star cast
- Megalopolis review by PV
I almost turned this off after 30 minutes. It's that sort of film.
Very confused, expensive, glossy spectacle, this is, interesting rather than enjoyable.
I felt NO emotional connection with ANy character - a problem when an audience has to care about characters when good or bad stuff happens to them.
Some great-looking scenes, a couple of shocks and twists. But the plot all seems very pointless.
Nice to see Giancarlo Esposito who shone so bright in Breaking Bad, and real movie stars too, like Dustin Hoffman, looking very doddery but then he is 87.
Not sure if it is meant to be a satire on the USA and Trump, but if so, it fails.
Watch GLADIATOR instead of 1964's CLEOPATRA or maybe THE RISE AND FALL OF THE ROMAN EMPIRE. Or goodie-v-baddie sci-fi like Star Wars.
1.5 stars rounded up.
4 out of 4 members found this review helpful.
Disastrous, overblown, unwatchable
- Megalopolis review by Alphaville
To be charitable, this is a bit of a mess. To be truthful, it’s a complete mess. Yes, it really is as bad as you’ve heard. All 2.15hrs of it. A waste of talent for all concerned, not just legendary director Coppola, but legendary actors such as Dustin Hoffman. Even young lead Adam Driver, for no reason whatsoever, is reduced at one stage to attempting Hamlet’s ‘To be or not to be’ speech. The idea being preached here is that modern-day New York is like ancient Rome heading for the Fall. The preachiness extends as far as a repetitive and irritating voiceover to ram it home.
What about the plot? You mean, there’s a plot? There have been many disastrous vanity projects in the history of the cinema. This is right up there among them. Oh, Francis, that it should come to this. Has he become so untouchable that no-one somewhere along the line could have had a quiet word in his ear?
3 out of 3 members found this review helpful.
Superb, riveted for 2 1/4 hrs
- Megalopolis review by JD
I know this has had a lot of average reviews but I was glued to the screen for the entire running time. I loved the conceit of attempting to make a Roman epic set in New York. Sure, elements are a mess, like Dustin Hoffman's character who seems to have wandered in from Goodfellas. There is also a sub-plot concerning an errant Soyuz about to crash into Earth that doesn't go anywhere. Anyway, sit back and enjoy the confusing but optimistic images.
1 out of 3 members found this review helpful.
Incomprehensible Mess
- Megalopolis review by GI
Francis Ford Coppola's passion piece, one he's been planning since the 80s, is an overblown, boring and weird to the point of being an incomprehensible mess. The art deco look of this alternative and/or futuristic look at America is interesting but the narrative that tries to replicate the Catiline plots of Ancient Rome is pretentious and dull. There are many moments when you have to try and unravel what's going on and eventually you just give up. Adam Driver, who seems very self conscious here, plays Cesar, a renowned architect in a New York now renamed New Rome. He has a vision for a new city using a building material he has discovered that also gives him some power over time. There's a conflict amongst the privileged class that is the main focus of the plot and involves such acting talents as Aubrey Plaza (who is the best thing on offer here), Shia LaBeouf, Jon Voight, Giancarlo Esposito, Laurence Fishburne, Nathalie Emmanuel and Dustin Hoffman and a few more. There's a surreal Lynchian element going on and at times I thought I was watching a Wes Anderson film and I suppose it could be argued that a Coppola failure outshines some successes by lesser directors but this is a high production bloated waste of time.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
A lifetime of ideas!
- Megalopolis review by F15HF1NG3RZ
Did I at any point have any understanding of what was going on? No.
Was the film entertaining? Yes
There was so much going on and so much expected of the viewer, but you can see what a passion project this had become for Coppola. All of the actors gave it their all and some have even said since they had no idea what their characters motivation was. Anyway, I thoughroughly enjoyed every aspect of Megalopolis and my only disappointment is that I missed its run at the cinema and it was only on for one week. Give it a try, you've not seen anything like it before! It certainly isn't boring.
0 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
Incomprehensible
- Megalopolis review by AB
I had no idea what was going on and I don't think the cast did either. Unconvincing in every way. Was Coppola making a tribute or an interpretation - it wasn't clear
0 out of 2 members found this review helpful.