Let’s start at the top: The Smashing Machine is a good film. Dwayne Johnson is even better—intense, wounded, and more human than he’s ever been, giving his most layered performance to date. Emily Blunt, as his partner, brings warmth and frustration in equal measure, though the story keeps its gaze on his inner bruises rather than the toll they take on her.
Benny Safdie directs with a sharp eye for texture—sweaty gyms, harsh lights, quiet despair. It recalls The Wrestler: the ache of performance, the loneliness of physical glory, the body as both weapon and cage. Still, there’s something missing—an emotional punch that never quite lands.
What remains is a fascinating portrait of masculinity in freefall: a man fighting not just opponents but himself, beautifully shot and bruisingly human, if just shy of knockout power.
I agree that the rock does give a layered and interesting performance of a wrestler that i have never heard of before.
But in my opinion this is too niche, too slow and too boring to sustain interest.
And yet again there is a loud annoying and intrusive jazz soundtrack vying for attention with the dialogue.
There is a reason why it didnt perform at the box office.
Only if you are a rock or wrestling fan.