Rent Alligator (1980)
3.1 of 5 from 67 ratings
1h 31min
I was expecting Robert Forster to be the best thing in it, but he’s only part of the pleasure. His lived-in performance gives the film real weight, while Lewis Teague packs the edges with small human details that stop it feeling like a disposable creature feature. There’s even a sly nod to The Third Man.
Alligator obviously owes something to Jaws, but the creature here is the better beast: nastier, more primal, and more fun. Best of all, its killing spree feels weirdly selective. This is a sewer monster with standards.
Bloodthirsty, yes, but oddly principled too. It bites harder than you’d expect.