All That Schubert
- The Piano Teacher review by griggs
Controlling your daughter’s life is a family tradition in Michael Haneke’s The Piano Teacher. Erika Kohut humiliates her piano students by day, then goes home to a mother who interrogates her like a truant fifteen-year-old.
Isabelle Huppert barely moves her face, yet you can see everything she’s holding down. One minute Erika’s terrifying, the next she’s a frightened child. I kept feeling sorry for her, even after she hid broken glass in a student’s coat pocket. That’s Huppert’s doing.
Haneke films it all with the warmth of a lab technician, which makes the nasty bits harder to sit through. Occasionally I could feel him arranging my discomfort. All that Schubert, and nobody in Vienna can manage a healthy emotion. Walter (Benoît Magimel), her new pupil, pursues her relentlessly, then balks when she puts her desires in writing.
Watching young Anna get drilled by her own pushy mother, I wondered how many more Erika Kohuts were being made.
2 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
An extremely warped, shocking & provocative psycho-sexual story with Huppert on stunning form
- The Piano Teacher review by Timmy B
I had never seen a Michael Haneke film, although had seen the enormous critical praise his work has attracted, especially the multiple plaudits for Amour & The White Ribbon. The only things I did know about him was that his work is extremely cold & abrasive and that he dives headfirst into provocative & often controversial subjects. After watching Elle, I was wanting to see more of Isabelle Huppert's work & this was one which came highly recommended, as well as winning her the Best Actress award at Cannes.
Erika Kohut is an extremely talented but highly dysfunctional woman. Whilst from the outside she looks like the picture of the perfect musician, revered for her teaching ability as well as her piano playing, the truth is anything but. Erika lives with her highly-strung & fastidiously controlling mother in a small flat which could quite easily double for Hell-on-Earth, even sleeping in the same room on beds next to each other. Erika is also completely warped sexually, both in her own actions as well as in her voyeuristic tendancies. Into this world comes Walter Klemmer, an attractive & talented young man who falls head over heels in love with Erika, but who quickly finds that she corrupts everyone she comes into contact with.
This film is like nothing I've ever watched, especially given when it was released (2001.) It doesn't vaguely insinuate or make reference to the sort of deviances Erika is obsessed with, it puts them right up on screen, punching you in the face & demanding that you process them. Whether it is the mutilation by her own hand or the revelling in the results of previous sexual activity, this is shown uncompromisingly & directly. And what is fascinating with that approach is that it takes all the sensationalism out of it. You watch a scene stripped of all gaudiness & get to the truth, however shocking, of Erika's life & tastes.
But what prevents this from descending into an empty shock fest is firstly the quality of the writing & direction and Huppert's performance. On the production side, the scenes are directed with a cold precision, ruthless in how they are staged. Haneke never gives any warmth to his settings, even in a situation like a piano recital in a gently-lit room with a welcoming audience. Erika's classroom is as sterile as an operating ward & even less welcoming. And her flat, instead of a sanctuary to rest & recuperate, is a maze of rooms with her mother scuttling about like a demonic cockroach and finding ever more hurtful ways to criticise her.
And then we come to Huppert's performance... I thought after watching Elle, I had seen the limits that Huppert could take things to, only to have this obliterated. Through Huppert's fearless & completely unselfconscious acting, we are shown a damaged but still fiercely independent woman, who is living in a world she cannot fit into, despite her very successful career. The fact that in one scene, we can feel sympathy, disgust & fascination with Erika all at the same time is a testament to Huppert's power & skill. Special mention must also go to Benoît Magimel as Walter. Despite his pretty-boy looks, once he gets entangled with Erika, you start to see him erode, whilst he desperately tries to cling on to the remaining decent & morality he has as a person.
This is not an easy film to watch. But it is fascinating, horrific & spellbinding all at once. And with Huppert at its centre, it becomes a rollercoaster ride you cannot get off. And nor do you want to.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.