







'Straw Dogs' is remembered as being one of the films which tested the limits of the old X certificate. The violence and (especially) the lingering rape scene were the talk of the pubs and the sixth-form playground of 1971. There is precious little else in the film to talk about.
Peckinpah may have a point that people are just as nasty, and just as prone to extreme behaviour in rural England as they are in urban America, and he has a very serious point in depicting humiliation being one of the drivers of conflict, but he needs characters who are much more than cardboard stereotypes, he needs a script that isn't laughably banal, and he needs actors who do not look as if they wish they were anywhere but on the set.
Peckinpah has Hoffman one minute standing up and acting the lad in an open top car, passionately kissing Susan George in full view of local workers, the next minute he's a repressed fuddy-duddy, interested in nothing but work. His wife, of course, wants all of the former and none of the latter. Told you this was a film of stereotypes. Everything is just a perfunctory prelude to the rape and the bloodbath.
Hoffman gives his usual nervy, mumbling performance. George could easily win many awards for beauty, but absolutely none for acting - though she is unfairly given the worst, most excruciating lines from a writer who presumably had never heard a woman open her mouth before. The suggestion that women may actually enjoy rape is the lowest point of this crass, nasty piece of work.
The film only becomes remotely watchable when the two greats Peter Vaughan and T.P. McKenna come on the screen. How they must have regretted appearing in such tripe.
This was director Sam Peckinpah's first film outside the western genre and it remains a strange and interesting addition to his work. It's also one of the key films of the 70s and one that has carried the taint of controversy ever since it was refused a home classification for video by the British Board of Film Classification until 2002. Whilst it's a dark crime drama there are the hallmarks of a paganist horror to it and Peckinpah creates a vision of Cornwall that is completely at odds with the beautiful holiday county that most people know. Dustin Hoffman and Susan George (in her first major role) are married couple David and Amy. He is a maths professor and they have come to Cornwall from the US so David can conduct his research for a thesis. They live at Amy's former family home near a quaint village where the villagers view David as bizarre and mock him at every opportunity. Some of the local men including one of Amy's former boyfriends take an unhealthy interest in her and when a girl goes missing and a local man is suspected events take an ugly turn. When David decides to help the suspected man Henry (David Warner) he and Amy find their home besieged by the local menfolk and David decides to make a stand. This film is often very misunderstood. Whilst this is a study of violence it is often thought to be one where a gentle man is pushed to his limits whereas it's more about the awakening of suppressed violence harboured by Hoffman's character, in that sense he's really the bad guy here. There's a controversial double rape scene that's used to highlight this but the point is often lost due to the emotional impact of how the rape scene plays out. In hindsight Peckinpah perhaps pushed his point too far although as screen violence goes this film isn't anywhere as graphic as other films since but it remains a powerful and nuanced study of a man unleashed into terrible violence and a relationship that balances on the edge of crisis. From the start you get the impression that David is fighting to keep his dark violence at bay. This is an important film, much respected today and definitely one I recommend if you've never seen it.
Very seventies, very violent film set in rural Cornwall. There are some inconsistencies of characterisation and plot, but on the whole this is a straightforward tale of envious have-nothings taking what they believe is their due from people they resent.
The locale and society in primitive, brooding western Cornwall are convincingly shown. The issues of justification for violence and the nature of sexual consent are not dealt with in a complex way, but the film does raise legitimate questions about them.
Hoffman is good as a man who is very intelligent but apparently tone-deaf to emotional matters , and Susan George makes the best of her role as his bored wife torn between two cultures. A very young Sally Thomsett plays the unwitting catalyst of tragedy, a teenage provocateuse, quite well.