Realistic Slice of Life
- Kes review by CP Customer
Acclaimed as Ken Loach's best film 'Kes' is a dark, depressing story of one boy who is given hope by training a rescued kestrel.
We really feel for Billy Casper as he seems destined for failure; both at school and with his family - particularly his brother who shows only hate to his younger sibling.
Loach creates a very plausible and realistic world that is hard to bear but almost impossible to pull away from.
6 out of 6 members found this review helpful.
Wings Above the Mud
- Kes review by griggs
I couldn’t quite remember watching Kes before, but Brian Glover’s booming voice on that football pitch rang loud enough to bring it all back — along with the pain of being forced to read the Barry Hines’ 1968 novel A Kestrel for a Knave at school. His scene, part comic and part cruel, was the fragment that lingered, flapping somewhere in memory until the rest of the film finally caught up.
Watching it again, properly this time, Loach’s portrait of Billy Casper feels painfully honest: a boy clinging to something pure in a world that barely notices him. There’s no sentimentality, just mud, hope, and the brief lift of wings before reality drags it all down.
It moves slowly, but that’s part of its truth — life doesn’t soar, it stumbles. Kes remains quietly devastating: a film that finds grace in small corners and reminds you what it feels like to dream, even when the world won’t let you.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Classic cinema
- Kes review by giantrolo
We enjoyed watching Kes, which felt like a really important piece of historical film making - including working down the pits, getting caned at school and showcasing the Barnsley accent! Not a cheery film by any stretch, and quite harrowing in parts, but really good nevertheless! Recommended!
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
A British Masterpiece
- Kes review by GI
Kes is a wonderful film adapted from a wonderful novel. It's a sad, heart warming and earnest story of a young boy, Billy, who lives on a Barnsley housing estate in the late 1960s. He has little future and no-one who actually cares either. His divorced mother shows no love and Billy has only his nasty, bullying brother as a role model. It's in his love of nature and the passion he finds in training a young kestrel that Billy has any hope of redemption. This is a sharp condemnation of British society and its education system based on harsh discipline and which ignores children like Billy. Anyone who was in school at this time will recognise the school scenes especially the comic yet tragic 'games' lesson with the fantastic Brian Glover as the PE Teacher who uses the lesson to live his own fantasy rather than give the children any sense of participation. The caning scene will also shock especially when you realise the actor playing the Headmaster was in fact an actual Headmaster! Indeed director Ken Loach used many non actors in the film giving it a realistic documentary-drama feel. Loach is famous for his socialist outlook but regardless of whether you agree with his politics he shines a very bright light on issues that cannot be ignored. The film touches on the mining community where the only hope for kids like Billy was a job in the coal mines. Billy rejects that future steadfastly throughout the film but the viewer is left with the knowledge that this is where he'll end up and of course in a few short years that industry will have died so watching the film today we know Billy has little to look forward to. This is a superb film and one everyone should make sure they see.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Key Loach.
- Kes review by Steve
A boy and his pet film, with a difference. It is a critique of an education system which is complicit in the failure of the child; who will be just another kid sent down the mines. David Bradley plays a lonely, neglected working class kid from a Yorkshire mining town who finds self worth through his relationship with the wild kestrel he raises from a chick.
The teachers do not engage with him. His father has gone and his mother does not love him. But through the falcon he develops a capacity to understand, nurture, and be more fulfilled. This isn't like Disney, where the boy's dreams would come true. He is destroyed by others who are just as damaged as himself. He exists in a hierarchy of bullying.
At the apex is the disinterested headteacher who aimlessly hands out corporal punishment. Or more comically the resentful, intimidating games coach (Brian Glover) who act's like he's Bobby Charlton. Loach shoots this in a social realist style: the cast are amateurs; scenes are improvised in real locations; action is shown in long shots without montage.
This environment is absolutely real and Bradley is enduringly authentic. Sometimes momentum is lost while the director spells out what he presumes is unfamiliar to the audience. But Ken Loach's polemic, adapted from Barry Hines' classroom classic, connected with the British public more than any of his other films.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.