On the surface, Mason Green (Joel Moore) seems to live a below-average life. Nervous and reclusive, he spends his days at work fielding mindlessly repetitive customer service calls. His only human contact comes from his narcissistic boss, Berkeley (Zachary Levi). Hardly a friend, Berkeley is still the only person who really reaches out to Mason. That is, until he meets Amber (Amber Tamblyn), a whimsical wallflower determined to break down his many barriers, and wake up the artist that lies deep within him. Armed with palate and brush, the two embark on a journey of friendship and discovery that may finally help the solitary man find the life balance he has always lacked. But the past that made Mason who he is still haunts him, and the love he now craves might just cause his quiet life to spiral totally out of control.