10 Cloverfield Lane (aka The Cellar) review by Mark McPherson - Cinema Paradiso
Sometimes it’s a good thing when a spin-off veers wildly off course from its predecessor. 10 Cloverfield Lane is a perfect example as a spiritual continuance of 2008’s Cloverfield. While its predecessor was a giant monster movie shot in the found-footage format, this picture ditches that tired cinematography device and even the giant monster angle. 10 Cloverfield Lane is actually a genuine surprise of a film in that it’s a highly effective bottle movie built atop marquee value. Is it a shameless attempt to bank off a name in order to get butts in the seats. You bet, but those suckered into seeing this movie will not be disappointed.
Michelle (Mary Elizabeth Winstead) finds herself locked in some sort of basement after having been hit in a car crash. She fears the worst from her new environment and her presumed beefy captor, Howard (John Goodman). After her shock wears off, she is baffled to discover she is inside Howard’s fully furnished bunker. There is plenty of oxygen, food, water and electricity for an extended stay. And that’s exactly what Howard intends for both Michelle and his other roommate Emmet. Unlike Michelle, Emmet wanted to get inside after what he witnessed topside. Howard’s bunker may be the safest place to be during the mash of monsters above, but his paranoia makes him the worst person to bunk with.
The character of Howard is an endlessly infatuating character as the audience and the rest of the cast attempt to decipher what’s going through his head. Little of his past family life is divulged as he directs more of the conversation to maintaining the bunker. He’s the most dangerous person in the bunker, but only in that he doesn’t trust anyone. Howard has clearly been preparing for this day for a long time and doesn’t want to fall for the easy traps that will doom him. Michelle and Emmet slowly realize they don’t want to be here, but Howard won’t let them usurp him. The slightest glance of the eye or subtle hint of secret code between the two is quickly shot down by an exploding Howard. But when not in a constant state of panic and strategy for survival, he tries his best to awkwardly bring a calm to the situation. One minute he’s threatening to kill everybody in the room under threat of suspicion, the next he’s quietly offering up a spaghetti dinner. This is some of John Goodman’s best work in years as an unstable, anti-social and incredibly creepy hermit.
As you might have guessed from this review and the trailers, 90% of the movie takes place inside the bunker. This is a bottle movie for taking place in one location, but it’s also one of the most intense and engaging movies of this type I’ve seen in a long time. Michelle and Emmet are conflicted with where they should be in this situation. Do you risk being attacked by the monsters outside or play it safe with the monster inside the bunker? The tough call of how to proceed amid the cabin fever makes for a very compelling story that can hit multiple beats. One scene could feature the trio enjoying a calm night of puzzles and the next could feature Howard holding them at gunpoint.
Do we ever get to see what goes on with the monster attack outside the bunker? Yes, but once we leave the bunker in the remaining few minutes of the picture you’ll be wondering why you ever wanted to leave. The last act of this movie does feature an outdoor scene with battling the monster/alien threat and it’s not at all as gripping. The aliens and their starships are not all that interesting, appearing as amalgamations of every alien design from the past decade of movies. It’s easy to tell that this segment was tacked on for the Cloverfield tie-in considering how out-of-place it appears in comparison to the rest of the movie. The bunker scenes end so perfectly that you can actually shut off the movie by that point and be satisfied with the experience.
Despite such an awkwardly generic second ending, 10 Cloverfield Lane is easily one of the best movies I’ve seen of 2016. Real character development and thriller drama trumps over the sci-fi tie-in nature of this title. It is rather sad that in order for such a movie to receive attention it needs a marquee title, but that’s the world we live in. It’s original title was The Bunker which I doubt would have gained much attention. But if it has to shoehorn in an alien action scene for a more engaging and human picture, it’s a great bargain. You don’t see too many movies about an alien attack that focus more on the characters than the special effects.