tombstone
- Tombstone review by CP Customer
crackingly paced well acted and good storyline,excellent soundtrack,quality cinematography,and as westerns go a classic.
enjoy.
3 out of 4 members found this review helpful.
A very good western without too many surprises
- Tombstone review by Philip in Paradiso
In around 1880, members of a gang of outlaws called 'The Cowboys' are in control of the town of Tombstone, in Arizona. When Wyatt Earp, a retired police officer, decides to settle down in the town to start a new life, together with his 2 brothers, Virgil and Morgan, and their respective wives, the 3 of them are soon in conflict with The Cowboys. This is the - true - story of the Wild West confrontation that led to the fight at the OK Corral, and what followed.
This is a very well-made and convincing movie, which is well-paced and well-acted, re-telling the well-known (and still fascinating) story of Wyatt Earp and the OK Corral gunfight. The film is without major surprises to anyone who knows the historical events, as it re-creates them in a generally faithful manner. It is a classically made western, albeit a fairly recently produced one (1993): it does not call the nature of the genre into question. Overall, I would certainly recommend the movie (more particularly if you enjoy westerns) and I enjoyed watching it, but I would not say it is a masterpiece. It is still a classic of the genre.
A footnote: There are some historical inaccuracies in the telling of the story, inevitably. One of them is that the fight did not actually take place at the OK Corral. See here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gunfight_at_the_O.K._Corral (This, in itself, is not important.)
Also, Wyatt Earp is somehow sanitized in the way he is portrayed in the film. There is no doubt he was a very courageous lawman, who never flinched in fist and gun fights. What the film does not dwell on is that, apart from his role in law enforcement, his entire life (not just the Tombstone episode) was largely devoted to gambling - if only running and owning bars that doubled up as, in effect, casinos. Also, the Earp brothers were involved with prostitutes. At one stage, Wyatt Earp himself was involved in pimping. One of his brothers ran a brothel for a period of time in another town. Wyatt Earp's partner, in the film, was actually a prostitute (or former prostitute), accurately depicted as addicted to laudanum. Finally, Wyatt Earp's other business interests involved mining.
2 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
A bit of a Muddle
- Tombstone review by griggs
Tombstone certainly looks the part; dusty saloons, thunderous shootouts, and all the trappings of a tremendous Western—but it's a bit of a muddle. There's a great film buried beneath too many characters and some choppy editing. However, Val Kilmer's performance is the clear standout, stealing scenes with a sly grin and death in his eyes. Watching it in the wake of his sad passing, his portrayal of Doc Holliday is a must-see. The story never quite finds its centre, but Kilmer's performance nearly makes it worth the ride. Watchable, sure—but it never quite lives up to its potential.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Great Cinematic Western
- Tombstone review by GI
A rip roaring western that is effectively pure cinema in that there is no attempt to make any sort of revisionist interpretation of the actual events here but simply portray a western like the classic films of old and simply retain myth over fact. In that sense it works brilliantly, is great fun with loads of bloody shoot outs, horseback chases and camera shots and angles homaging many other films. If you were in any doubt the film opens with a shot from the cinematically famous 1903 film, The Great Train Robbery. The principle influence is that of Sergio Leone, which if you're familiar with his westerns are similarly cinematic rather than historically influenced. Whilst Tombstone is based around real characters and events it makes no effort nor claim to be anything other than fiction. The famous Gunfight At The OK Corral has been the subject of numerous films and the events leading up to it, the actual gunfight and thereafter have been portrayed in a variety of ways. Here the first half of the film is about town/frontier taming, a regular subject of westerns, then the iconic gunfight centralises the film and afterwards it's one long, exciting revenge tale. Kurt Russell is former lawman Wyatt Earp who arrives, with his brothers, in the mining town of Tombstone. He shuns requests to put on a badge but eventually is forced back to being Marshall when threatened by a violent gang led by Curly Bill (Powers Boothe) and Johnny Ringo (Michael Biehn). Aided by Doc Holliday (a sensational Val Kilmer) they have to bring law & order to the west mainly by killing a lot of people. The cast are exceptional including Sam Elliott, Bill Paxton, Billy Bob Thornton and Charlton Heston has a cameo with Robert Mitchum providing a short narration. Even if you don't like westerns this is a contemporary example of action cinema that is great from start to finish so it's definitely worth your time if you haven't seen it.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.