Rent The Duellists (1977)

A man's gotta do what a man's gotta do... - The Duellists review by Count Otto Black

The minimal plot of Ridley Scott's debut film puts Keith Carradine's thoroughly decent hero in a classic nightmare scenario. Due to the conventions of his time, class, and profession, he is obliged to put honor above all else and, if necessary, fight duels for extremely minor reasons, and he has the misfortune to offend a completely bonkers fellow officer (Harvey Keitel) who insists that they fight to the death for essentially no reason at all. And, like the Terminator, Keitel's psychotic antagonist simply will not stop until one of them is dead. Which would make this a very short film, were it not for the repeated failure of both men to finish the job.

The atmosphere of the Napoleonic Wars is beautifully realized, and although the modest budget doesn't permit any battles to be shown, we're constantly aware of the effect the conflict is having on everybody (in this respect, as well as the increasingly obsessive adversarial relationship between two protagonists who seldom meet, it's similar to "Witchfinder General", which I suspect may have been a major influence). And the multiple duels are excellent, running the full gamut from gentlemanly swordplay to bloody savagery to mirror the escalating irrationality of why these men are trying to kill each other.

Where it falls down a bit is that Ridley Scott's weaknesses are on show almost as much as his strengths. Stacy Keach inexplicably provides a voice-over (thankfully not very often) even more insulting to the viewers' intelligence than the one in "Blade Runner", and sometimes, especially in the last third, he's so busy showing us the "Pride And Prejudice"-style good life c. 1800 that the pace flags badly.

Also, although Keith Carradine is mostly pretty good, there's one scene where he shows the absolute terror of a man forced to risk his life for an utterly senseless reason which had me thinking that if his entire performance had been like that, I would have been on the edge of my seat, instead of frequently noticing how well the scenery was filmed (or occasionally wasn't). If an actor is capable of giving that kind of performance some of the time, a truly great director will concentrate on getting it out of him all of the time. Instead, Scott ruins that particular scene with clumsy, confusing flashbacks and muddled continuity, as if he's making a 30-second commercial for hitting people with swords on horseback.

This is a good film (with a very unexpected yet oddly perfect ending), but it's no masterpiece. In particular, I would have liked Harvey Keitel's one-dimensional villain to have been given far more characterization, because although Keitel is very convincing indeed, there's only so much you can do with a cardboard cutout. And watch out for the scene near the end where a tense situation is rendered Pythonesque by the meaningless inclusion of the rear half of what is clearly a stuffed donkey. You'll definitely know it when you see it...

Beautiful Period Drama - The Duellists review by GI

Director Ridley Scott's film debut and a remarkable, astonishingly beautiful one too. Famed, even possibly notorious, for his dedication to the visual presentation of his films this is a film highly detailed in every scene and the soft focus hues create a landscape of autumnal beauty that is rarely matched. The mise en scene throughout is fantastic with every scene carefully and meticulously constructed like a classical painting. Set in the early 19th century this tells the tale of two officers in Napoleon's army, D'Hubert (Keith Carradine) and Feraud (Harvey Keitel). When the fiery Feraud takes offence at D'Hubert for delivering a message from their superior he insists they fight a duel. This starts a lifelong animosity between them which is realised through a series of duels. Each becomes more intense and violent as the years go by until Napoleon is eventually deposed and D'Hubert retires to a quiet life in the country but Feraud soon returns. As a period drama this is a film that exudes a romantic time tinged with constant war, a story of honour, obsession and love. It marked Scott as a filmmaker of great skill and unique style and in many ways it's a film that paved the way for his later classic films, especially in the amazing detail applied. The support cast are excellent and include Albert Finney, Edward Fix, Diana Quick and Cristina Raines. Highly original, great story and wonderfully directed this is a masterpiece.