Over-long, Disjointed but Watchable 'Politically Correct' Movie
- Zero Dark Thirty review by PV
This film is not bad - it is watchable if very VERY long. More like 2 or 3 episodes of a TV drama stuck together though than one cohesive story. Maybe that's because it ranges over 12 years and several countries? Maybe the story would be better served by TV though if that is the case?
This is also one of those films that shows history which is not history, but rather wish fulfilment of Hollywood producers and writers. According to this script, a lone woman - who is of course utterly courageous, compassionate, and superior to all men present (who are against her initially) - is responsible for the talking out of Osama Bin Laden. Yeah right. Sadly, a lot of people will believe this hogwash as fact - and Bigelow really does not need to stoop to such feminist propaganda levels either.
But it's a competent if unexciting movie - and is perhaps best in its initial scenes (which unusually for a US movie show the US forces in a bad light) and its final scenes (which are exciting to watch). Some well-drawn characters (oddly, the men are much better drawn as characters than the heroin women), interesting scenes, and a sense of menace in Pakistan and Afghanistan which is certainly true to life.
So average then - 3 stars.
Subtitles are recommended too even if you aren't hard of hearing, just to understand what everyone is saying over the noise!
1 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
- Zero Dark Thirty review by SM
The subject matter is ostensibly interesting but the film itself is boring and hugely overrated.
The main character is completely one-dimensional - after nearly 3 hours I knew nothing about her except that she worked for the CIA.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
An emotionally detached film
- Zero Dark Thirty review by RP
Kathryn Bigelow has directed an Oscar-winning followup to her previous Oscar-winner 'The Hurt Locker'. Only this time the Oscar was not for 'Best Picture', but (bizarrely, given the fact you'll probably need to use the subtitles to hear what's going on) for 'Best Sound Editing'. And that gives a clue - it isn't 'best picture' quality.
The film is a lengthy (2½ hours) pseudo documentary on the 10 year hunt for Osama Bin Laden, starting in September 2001 and culminating in his shooting in a raid on his compound in Pakistan in May 2011. The first 2 hours of the film deals with the questioning and torture of assorted detainees to obtain information and the following of several dead end leads, with the lead character (Maya, well played by Jessica Chastain) focusing relentlessly on a single named but unidentified suspect, a courier for Bin Laden. The final ½ hour covers the raid.
The film is a drama - but I didn't find it very dramatic. Yes, bits of it were tense, but frankly I can't see what the excitement was about. The characterisation was shallow, the events shown were simple snapshots, there was no placing of the events into a wider context. The attack on the World Trade Center led to not only a manhunt for Bin Laden but to full scale wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. And an attempt in the film to place the July 2005 London bombings in that context is misguided as these were carried out by home-grown terrorists without help from al-Qaeda / Bin Laden. I found the focus on a few individual CIA operatives to be a very shallow device, and if I can spot errors in the film it makes me wonder what other errors there are. But hey, this is a Hollywood movie...
The film left me cold. It's an emotionally detached film whose central character is recruited out of high school by the CIA and the single assignment she has worked on is the hunt for Bin Laden, has no friends, no boyfriends. I didn't feel any involvement with the characters nor the subject matter, which was (perhaps understandably) relentlessly US-oriented. I wasn't moved by the waterboarding / torture scenes. I certainly didn't enjoy it - but then it's not the kind of film you 'enjoy'. And I didn't like it very much.
I did enjoy the appearance of the late James Gandolfini as the CIA Director - despite his f-ing and blinding, I understand that at least was true to life...
3/5 stars. Pretty average stuff for me.
0 out of 1 members found this review helpful.