Read the book first.
- 1984 (Nineteen Eighty Four) review by WP
My only gripe with this film is they must presume everyone has read Orwell's 1984. If you haven't you may find this film hard to follow. Too often key points or changes are not made apparent enough to the viewer. This being the case, the film fails to equal the book in any area. It's a pity as Hurt's acting is excellent, and the film certainly gives out the right atmosphere.
2 out of 3 members found this review helpful.
Quite good
- 1984 (Nineteen Eighty Four) review by SB
This version of Orwell's 1984 is well performed by its three leads, even though Burton apparently had difficulty with lines. I wonder if that may account for the fact that the scenes where Winston Smith is re-educated are somewhat shorter than might have been justified. But the horrible totalitarian milieu, the drudgery of everyday life, the manipulation of information are well drawn. Suzanna Hamilton ably suggests both warm humanity and a certain ambiguity as Smith's lover - who does she really work for, apart from herself? Parallels with today, Trump etc can be over-stretched but this is still very thought provoking.
2 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
upsetting and compelling
- 1984 (Nineteen Eighty Four) review by AER
This the best film adaptation we could have ever hoped for. Based on George Orwell's classic novel of the same title, this distills all the landmark moments from the book and it's gripping, sad and ultimately crushing. Perfectly cast, the principal trio, John Hurt, Suzanna Hamilton (who ended up in TV's Casualty!!) and in his last role, Richard Burton, all put in note perfect performances. It's a spooky, sad, and upsetting film. The futility of everything permeates everything. CLASSIC>
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
Who Do You Love?
- 1984 (Nineteen Eighty Four) review by Steve
This intelligent adaptation of George Orwell's landmark novel of ideas is inevitably a downbeat experience, but also incisive and horrifying. As well as the topicality of its release in 1984, the intention was to re-imagine the text as dystopian science fiction, though the script is actually scrupulously faithful to the author's ideas.
Sometimes these are spun into dialogue or the voice over of Winston Smith as he begins to lose faith in the totalitarianism of future Britain. He even reads out lines from a manual! This isn't always cinematic, but still philosophically thrilling! Okay, it helps to know the novel, but then... it's among the most widely read books ever.
All of its concepts are here, including the impression of the nation stuck between WWII and the threat of Stalinism. The incredibly muted colour palette is appropriately dour, but still allows optimistic colour to seep into Winston's illusion of freedom. And John Hurt makes one of the most iconic names in literature live and breath.
Richard Burton is intellectually terrifying as O'Brien, while Suzanna Hamilton makes Winston's hazardous romance with Julia into a heartbreaker. Where Orwell is schematic, director Michael Radford brings in glum realism. The novel is often called unfilmable... Well... perhaps. It's certainly difficult to imagine it could be done better.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.