(Un)happy families
- The Squid and the Whale review by Kurtz
An unflinching and at times darkly comic portrayal of the break-up of a family of American intellectuals, this is Laura Linney territory and she is excellent as ever as the wife who has outgrown her pompous loser of a husband. Jeff Daniels is brilliant in this role, creating an appallingly petty character full of bitterness over the absence of the literary success he feels he deserves, but still winning a few shreds of sympathy for the indignities he suffers. The kids are hapless bystanders in this conflict, but they are convincing too, especially Jesse Eisenberg’s “daddy clone”, who nails just the right combination of arrogance and insecurity. Just like in real life, no-one is completely at fault for the break-up, and no-one is completely innocent; the family just seem to have got to the end of their time together. Not a bundle of laughs, but beautifully done.
3 out of 4 members found this review helpful.
Superb look at a civilised break up.
- The Squid and the Whale review by CP Customer
I loved every minute of 'The Squid And The Whale', the idea of creating a film around a family in which both parents are liberal minded intellectuals, who make the decision the break up in a very adult and civilised manner was very smart. And what adds to the film is the fact that the more the parents attempt to be civilised, the more unreasonable and destructive they actually become. And while the film is labelled as a comedy, it is far more subtle and dark than laugh out loud comedy, so if you're expecting laughs you're going to be disappointed, but of you enjoy small character based films them this is well worth a rental.
2 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
Letting Go
- The Squid and the Whale review by Steve
Middlebrow divorce comedy based on the breakup of Noah Baumbach's parents while he was a teenager growing up in Brooklyn, New York. Along with the droll satire and wry witticisms there's an impression of raw personal experience. But it could have been inspired by the Modern Parents in Viz... and the script is ostentatiously influenced by Woody Allen.
Except for the stoical mother, the self-absorbed family is hard to like, yet those who experienced this as a child may feel an ache of recognition. It's not a heavy drama but it still conveys the trauma. Jesse Eisenberg plays an astonishingly supercilious adolescent whose personality is distorted by the narcissism of his father (Jeff Daniels), a writer in decline...
It's incredible his clever, levelheaded wife (Laura Linney) tolerated her husband's egotism for more than a weekend. Yet they have a second child (Owen Kline) now entering puberty without much guidance. The wife's own debut novel has been well received and has a very different boyfriend (William Baldwin). So the friction with her ex begins to catch fire.
It's a concise film, like a screen version of a short story, which doesn't slow down in search of profundity. There is a detailed introduction to the vulnerabilities of the divided family and some understated warmth at the fadeout. Plus a feel for bourgeoise suburban Brooklyn in the 1990s. It was an impressive breakthrough for the director, which he hasn't yet equalled.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.