- I Am Legend review by Rob S
Having not seen the other filmed interpretations of this story and not having read the book, I came to this not knowing anything more than what I had heard and read in other reviews. I was therefore expecting to be disappointed as that seems to be the general critical opinion of this piece, to such a degree that I only recently placed this in my list. I'm pleased to say that I thought this was a great movie with some excellent scenes (especially when Smith - who is excellent in this btw, follows his dog into the dark, as well as the opening sequence with the red Ford Mustang - great shots of an empty, overgrown NY City). Most people seem to have an issue with the creatures, but I must say that I thought they were OK. Certainly scary and believable - yes, they probably could have been done better, but hey, didn't spoil it fo me.
The film itself resolves itself nicely and makes sense, which is more than can be said for many movies. So all in an entertaining film and better than the critics will have you believe.
In terms of extras, it's very disappointing with only a few animated comics which relate to the story, but there is no making of etc.
The one thing that did impress me was the picture quality of this disc - really stunning and looked like HD to me, especially the opening sequence.
Overall recommended and scores a 4.5 out of 5.
2 out of 4 members found this review helpful.
I've seen worse
- I Am Legend review by RP
Let's get it out of the way: I don't like Will Smith films. He's too over-the-top for me, too excitable, too silly, too mouthy. Unfortunately 'I Am Legend' stars Will Smith, so guess what - I didn't like the film. It's also yet another remake – the story has been filmed 4 times so far.
Based on Richard Matheson's classic 1954 novel it tells a similar story of a man alone after a global pandemic turns the population into vampiric zombie type creatures who come out at night. It is supposedly a study in loneliness – here, Will Smith is alone but for his dog.
There are a few silly bits: the infection is caused by a virus originally intended to cure cancer, and the doctor responsible is a Dr Krippen. Will Smith rents videos (he's word perfect at 'Shrek') and in his loneliness is apparently attracted to shop mannequins.
Anyway, unlike in the novel where the central Richard Neville character stands as a lone survivor killing the infected to whom he becomes 'Legend', here he finds a woman survivor who delivers the 'cure' to a colony of other survivors. Mawkish stuff and clumsily done.
2/5 stars – I have seen worse.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.