3.10 to yuma
- 3:10 to Yuma review by CP Customer
not a bad attempt at a western,but why?/ the first was great,this is ok but one asks why bother unless better or as good??
worth a watch.
2 out of 4 members found this review helpful.
An average Western with moderate performances
- 3:10 to Yuma review by Timmy B
Back when there was a sudden resurgence of interest in the Western genre, multiple films were made, some great, some not so great. This firmly falls into the latter. Despite having an amazing cast, with Russell Crowe on anti-hero duties and Christian Bale as the disabled, impoverished ranch hand who is offered a massive payday to transport Crowe’s character to the 3:10 prison train, it never truly catches fire and takes flight.
The film itself tries to deal with many heavy subjects, some of which it does quite well. It is especially well-shown how painful it is for Bale’s character to not be the father he feels they deserve. But there are also many slow moments and as much as there is the big action scene at the end, it is in many ways too little too late. Crowe also gives in many ways an autopilot performance, which is a shame considering how good he can be.
But the film itself is very well-shot and the rollcall of actors means that it is never boring to be around. I just wished it had been more than this. However, it is absolutely a 3-star film and worth a watch.
1 out of 1 members found this review helpful.
A classic genre revisited
- 3:10 to Yuma review by Pete W
Remember all those westerns that used to be on TV on a Sunday afternoon? Well this is out of the same stable but updated for the 21st century. Solid performances from Russell Crowe and Christian Bale in the lead roles and a storyline that holds the attention with constant twists and turns. Special mention for Ben Foster as a psychopathic outlaw who gets what he deserves in the end from an unexpected source.
1 out of 2 members found this review helpful.
Western schtik, by numbers.
- 3:10 to Yuma review by IanF
3:10 to Uma is ok, but for me the ending lets it down. The action, especially at the end, seemed driven by computer games violence, with no logic or believability.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.
Keep Watching Its Worth It
- 3:10 to Yuma review by CP Customer
Not necessarly everyones type of film but definatey worth a recommendation. I loved the ending it ( I wont give it away) but wasnt what I was expecting. Not the normal type of western but well worth a looksee
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.
Violent Western Remake - OKish
- 3:10 to Yuma review by GI
Basically a remake of the classic psychological western of the same name made in 1957 and adapted from a 1953 short story. This newer version follows the general trend of modern westerns in that it ups the action and brutal violence to appeal to a modern day audience. It's tempting to make a comparison to the '57 film which was kept rigidly to the standard western character trope of honour and stoic manhood and is a classic of the genre and eschews too much gunplay for a more subtle comparison of two men on opposite sides of a moral divide. Director James Mangold brings a revisionist edge to his newer film that is more about the redemption for the outlaw that never quite takes place, leaving him as basically selfish to the end despite his apparent protection of his captor. The two lead stars, Russell Crowe and Christian Bale, are nevertheless fully committed in their characters with Crowe getting the best lines and the more riveting presence but overall, even without recalling the 1957 film, this is a routine, violent western that has some entertainment value but offers little else. The story follows farmer Dan (Bale), crippled in the Civil War and now struggling with debts and an aggressive landlord, but is devoted to his wife and two sons. The eldest (Logan Lerman) is a headstrong, stubborn boy who is eternally disappointed in his father. Opportunity comes when a notorious outlaw, Wade (Crowe) is arrested and Dan agrees to take him to the train station in the next town for a reward that will free him of debt. On the journey he has to battle Indians, a mining gang and Wade's own men. This cues bloody shoot outs and fast action. The film lacks the slow build up of tension in the wait for the train that marks the original as a great western. It's all ok but offers little that's new.
0 out of 0 members found this review helpful.